Sterling Silver: Antique Elegance & Designer Masterpieces

Discover the Hidden Value in Your Collection with Sal Lanzieri

At Judy’s Jewelry, we don’t just see silver by the ounce—we see it by the era, the artist, and the artistry. From the intricate floral patterns of Victorian-era brooches to the bold, modernist lines of mid-century Scandinavian designers, sterling silver is a medium of endless variety. Sal Lanzieri and his nephew JP specialize in identifying and valuing high-end silver jewelry that others might overlook.

Why Your Silver is Worth More at Judy’s

Many “gold buyers” treat silver as an afterthought. At Judy’s, we recognize that the hallmark (the stamp on the back) can change the value of a piece from a few dollars to a few hundred. Sal’s 35 years of experience allows him to quickly identify rare makers and collectible styles.

  • Expert Identification of Hallmarks: We specialize in identifying American, British, and Continental silver marks. Whether it’s the “925” stamp, the Lion Passant, or a rare designer signature, we know what to look for.

  • Native American & Southwestern Art: Sal has a deep appreciation and market knowledge for vintage Navajo, Zuni, and Hopi silverwork, including squash blossom necklaces and turquoise-inlay cuffs.

  • Designer Brands: We pay premium prices for signed pieces from world-renowned makers like Tiffany & Co., David Yurman, Georg Jensen, John Hardy, and James Avery.

Our Silver Specialization

We buy, sell, and appraise a vast collection of silver items, with a focus on:

  • Vintage Sterling Jewelry: Heavy silver chains, cuff bracelets, and statement rings from the early to mid-20th century.

  • Mexican Silver: Highly collectible Taxco silver jewelry from the “Golden Age” of Mexican design (Bernice Goodspeed, Los Castillo, Spratling).

  • Antique Accessories: Victorian silver lockets, Edwardian hatpins, and Art Nouveau buckles.

  • Estate Lots: We are the largest buyer of estate jewelry in Fort Myers—we handle everything from single pieces to entire silver collections found in local estate liquidations.

Dealing with “The Largest Buyer in SWFL”

When you bring your silver to Judy’s Jewelry, you aren’t dealing with a clerk behind a glass partition. You are sitting down with Sal or JP. We use professional-grade testing and magnification to ensure your sterling is authentic and that you are receiving a fair, transparent offer based on current market demand—not just the daily silver “spot” price.

Have a collection you’d like to sell? Silver tarnishes, but its value doesn’t. Don’t clean your antique silver before bringing it in—the “patina” can often tell us more about its age and authenticity. Visit our Fort Myers shop today for a professional evaluation.

Vintage Sterling Silver Butterscotch Amber Brutalist Bracelet
Vintage 925 Sterling Silver Turquoise Color Stone Choker/Necklace
Vintage Sterling Silver One Dollar Coin Turquoise & Red Coral Cuff Bracelet
Judys Jewelry logo

Items can be returned within 30 days with receipt for store credit only.
NO REFUNDS or CASH BACK . We do handle Estate Sales

Judys Jewelry logo

Items can be returned within 30 days with receipt for store credit only.
NO REFUNDS or CASH BACK . We do handle Estate Sales

Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved. Judy’s Jewelry Antique and Estate Jewelry. Privacy Policy.

Location: 12710 McGregor Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33919 • Website by Visitivity Inc.

Serving Fort Myers, Cape Coral, Lehigh Acres, Bonita Springs, Estero, Fort Myers Beach, Sanibel, Alva, North Fort Myers, Captiva, Bokelia, Buckingham, McGregor, Naples, Marco Island, Florida